Crypto tax audit

A crypto tax audit is a tax authority's examination of a return to check that income and gains from digital assets were reported correctly, which the IRS starts by mail and carries out by mail or in an interview. It is a different thing from the educational letters the IRS has sent to crypto holders, numbered 6173, 6174 and 6174-A, of which only Letter 6173 asks for a reply by a set date.

How many returns the IRS examined

How likely is a crypto tax audit in the US? The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration measured it in report 2024-300-030 of July 10, 2024, and found coverage it called “insignificant.”

Finding Figure As of
Small business and self-employed examinations with a digital asset component 1,144 of 365,391 (0.31%) Fiscal 2020 to May 2023
Taxpayers examined using the 2018 John Doe summons data from Coinbase 216, plus nearly 15,000 “soft letters” June 2023
Closed underreporter cases on 2020 returns with digital assets that ended in more tax 948 of 1,315, over $27.3 million, average $28,832 March 2023
Criminal Investigation cases involving virtual currency 390, of which 224 recommended for prosecution Fiscal 2018 to 2023

The report adds that Operation Hidden Treasure, presented as a joint criminal and civil effort, had so far been “limited to the acquisition of tools and training, rather than pursuing taxpayers.” IRS staff told the inspector general that broker data on Form 1099-DA would let them match returns against third-party reports.

A letter is not an audit

Many crypto holders who hear from the IRS get a letter rather than an examination. In news release IR-2019-132 of July 26, 2019, the agency said more than 10,000 taxpayers would receive one of three educational letters by the end of August that year.

The texts differ in one way that matters. Letter 6173 carries a respond-by date and warns that without an answer “we may refer your tax account for examination.” Letter 6174 and Letter 6174-A both say “You do not need to respond to this letter,” and the 6174-A adds that more correspondence may follow.

How a real audit starts

The IRS’s audit page says an audit is notified by mail and that “we won’t initiate an audit by telephone.” It generally covers returns filed within the last three years, can add years when a substantial error turns up, and usually goes back no more than six. A phone call announcing an audit therefore does not match how the IRS says it begins one.

The UK version

HMRC runs its own channel for owning up. Its disclosure service for unpaid tax on cryptoassets, published on November 29, 2023, says you pay what you owe for up to 4 years if you took care, 6 if you were careless and 20 if the shortfall was deliberate.

If a letter arrives, compare its number and wording with the IRS’s published copies before acting on it. This entry is general information and not tax or legal advice.

Where it comes up