Fair market value

Fair market value is the price an asset would sell for between a willing buyer and a willing seller who both know the relevant facts and are under no pressure to deal. In US crypto tax it is the dollar value of coins at the moment you receive them, which sets the income you report and becomes your cost basis.

Two exchanges, one second, one ether

What was one ether worth at 05:27:23 UTC on November 11, 2026? Exchange Coinbase’s public price feed said $2,065.835. Kraken’s ticker, read in the same second, showed a last trade at $2,065.35, under 50 cents lower.

The clock mattered far more than the venue. The same Kraken reading put ether’s range over the previous 24 hours at $2,002.00 to $2,129.15, a swing of $127.15, going by the field definitions in the exchange’s API documentation, which label the second number in each pair as the last 24 hours.

Picture a freelancer paid 0.5 ETH at that moment. Income comes to about $1,033 at either exchange, a gap of 24 cents. Priced at the day’s low or high instead, it would have been $1,001 or $1,065, which is why the exact time of receipt has to be recorded.

The IRS’s yardstick

The definition comes from the IRS’s guide to valuing donated property. Publication 561 calls fair market value “the price that property would sell for on the open market,” agreed between a willing buyer and a willing seller “with neither being required to act.”

For crypto, the agency ties that value to a moment. Two answers carry most of it. Answer 58 of its digital asset FAQ, for transactions from 2025 on, values coins received for services “measured in U.S. dollars, when received.” Answer 59 then makes the same number your cost basis, provided you report it as income.

The older virtual currency FAQ, written for transactions before 2025, says more about sources. Answer 26 takes the dollar amount an exchange records for the trade. For a peer-to-peer payment, answer 27 accepts a value from “a cryptocurrency or blockchain explorer that analyzes worldwide indices” at the exact date and time.

When there is no price at all

Some tokens trade nowhere. In that case answer 28 of the older FAQ values them at whatever was given for them, goods or services, and answer 102 of the newer one runs the other way for hard-to-value property, measuring it by the coins you handed over.

An IRS memo on the Bitcoin Cash fork of 2017 allowed “any reasonable method,” and Revenue Ruling 2019-24 uses one figure twice, as income from an airdrop and as the basis of the new coins.

Where you see it

A broker’s Form 1099-DA reports proceeds in box 1f, and the instructions say total proceeds may include digital assets or other property received in exchange. The IRS digital assets page also asks for records showing the dollar value of every coin received as income or as payment in a trade or business.

A price is not an appraisal

The costly mistake comes with gifts to charity. In Chief Counsel Advice 202302012, released on January 13, 2023, the taxpayer in the memo’s facts claimed a $10,000 deduction for donated crypto using the price an exchange listed, with no appraisal.

The memo concluded that any deduction over $5,000 needs a qualified appraisal and that relying on the exchange price didn’t count as reasonable cause, so she would not be allowed the deduction. It isn’t precedent, but answer 78 of the newer FAQ states the same $5,000 rule.

Read as an explanation of the term, not as tax advice.

Where it comes up